Summary
- Tawny Newsome's involvement in Starfleet Academy sparks mixed reactions among Star Trek fans.
- Fans worry that Newsome's comedy background could clash with the tone of Star Trek.
- Newsome assures fans of her commitment to canon accuracy and hopes to deliver a nuanced and respectful portrayal in the new series.
With the 2026 release of Star Trek: Starfleet Academy looming, fans have questions, concerns, and more than a few feelings about Lower Decks voice actor Tawny Newsome joining the project. Her presence has the Star Trek community split like a Romulan secret directive.
Currently in production, Starfleet Academy has a stacked cast that includes Paul Giamatti as the villain and promises a bold new chapter in the Star Trek franchise—one centered on a younger generation of cadets navigating life, learning, and high-stakes interstellar science. The addition of Newsome to the writers’ room, known primarily for voicing the chaotic-good Ensign Beckett Mariner on Star Trek: Lower Decks, has stirred up a cocktail of excitement, hesitation, and good old-fashioned Federation-level fan discourse.
JJ Abrams Got a Lot Wrong About Star Trek, But the Franchise Still Owes Him Credit For This
Longtime Trekkies claim J.J. Abrams ruined Star Trek, but his contributions to the franchise paved the way for the Trek of today.
Why Are Trekkies So Divided Over Tawny Newsome Writing For Starfleet Academy?
Newsome isn’t new to Trek, and she’s certainly not a stranger to a script. She's made her mark across multiple creative disciplines—comedy, music, podcasting, and acting. But her voice work on Lower Decks put her squarely in the heart of the Star Trek conversation. As Mariner, she brought both a rebellious edge and vulnerability to the show that straddles parody and tribute. In episodes like “Crisis Point,” a satirical take on Trek’s cinematic tendencies, or “We'll Always Have Tom Paris,” where hallucinations of the famed Voyager helmsman lead to hilarious chaos, Newsome helped craft something that both pokes fun at and deeply honors Star Trek canon.
Despite that, the idea of her writing for Starfleet Academy—a live-action drama meant to capture younger, possibly first-time Trek fans—has left some longtime viewers wary. “How about getting a WRITER,” one Reddit user wrote. Another added harshly, “Gilmore Girls writing levels is not what I seek.” Their concern isn’t that Newsome doesn’t know Trek—it’s that she doesn’t have a very long writing resume. And most of the writing she has done has been comedy.
Critics of the decision also argue that even if she did make creative contributions to Lower Decks, the animated show is too irreverent to be a tonal match—and fans have been burned before. Discovery’s shift from classic Trek space exploration to serialized action and melodrama alienated some longtime fans. Even Picard’s dystopian introspection didn’t sit right with viewers hoping for a return to TNG's hopeful spirit. The fear is that Starfleet Academy could veer into teen drama tropes or comedic excess instead of delivering the nuanced morality tales that defined episodes like TNG's “The Measure of a Man” or DS9's “Duet.”
Tawny Newsome Wants to Make Starfleet Academy Canon-Conscious and Credible
If Newsome’s heard the skepticism—and she has—she’s not brushing it off. Instead, she’s taken a direct approach, speaking to fans’ concerns in recent interviews. “I think people hear ‘comedy writer’ and think I’m going to turn Starfleet Academy into a sketch show,” she said. “But I know what show I’m working on. And I love Star Trek — deeply.”
In an interview with TrekMovie, Newsome emphasized that canon integrity is a top priority. “We’ve got canon cops in the room. We’ve got people with encyclopedic Trek knowledge. You know, I’ve got every ship memorized, every admiral’s name memorized. We’re ready,” she said. This commitment to detail and respect for established lore is precisely what some fans needed to hear.
She’s not wrong about the assumptions. But Newsome’s critics might be overlooking her ability to shift tone. In Lower Decks, Mariner isn’t just a walking punchline. Her complicated relationship with authority—especially her Starfleet Admiral mother, Carol Freeman—adds emotional weight. Episodes like “No Small Parts” balance quippy dialogue with life-or-death stakes and real character growth. It’s not just funny—it’s Trek.
That’s the side of Newsome her supporters point to. “I love Lower Decks[.] Newsome is someone I’m starting to put in the ‘give the benefit of the doubt’ category,” one fan wrote. Many agreed, with one user adding, “Tawny is the best thing to come out of new [T]rek.” To them, bringing her into the room isn’t a gamble—it’s a chance to get things right. Many fans even expressed that Newsome’s involvement actually increased their interest in a show they might’ve otherwise overlooked.
“Hollywood is full of psychopaths, and they really managed to find some sweeties who love Trek. I’ve been having a blast and I think that the audience is going to love the show. I really do.” - Newsome
What The Franchise's History Says About Comedy Vs. Drama In Star Trek
The Original Series had Spock dryly roasting McCoy. The Next Generation gave us Data’s search for laughter and Riker’s jazz phase. Deep Space Nine featured Quark as a Ferengi foil amidst war and existential crisis. Even Voyager had The Doctor’s sardonic wit offering relief from the Delta Quadrant’s endless threats. In the right hands, humor complements drama rather than undercutting it. Even in its most serious incarnations, humor has always been part of Star Trek's DNA, and for that matter, so has hiring actors in creative roles behind the camera.
While Lower Decks leans hard into comedy, it’s often through those funny moments that serious Trek themes emerge: what it means to serve, to lose, to question command, and to confront legacy. The show doesn’t just know Trek—it understands it. That’s part of what makes Newsome’s involvement such a wildcard. She's proven she can deliver both comedy and weight. The question is whether she can recalibrate for a writers' room and a live-action format that plays by different rules.
The Raised Stakes For Starfleet Academy And The Future Of Star Trek As A Whole
Every new Star Trek show shoulders the expectations of a franchise that’s been evolving since 1966 and its extremely passionate fanbase. Starfleet Academy will be the first major series focused entirely on cadets. The potential is huge: new faces, untapped themes, and the opportunity to examine the Federation’s ideals through fresh eyes.
That makes the choice of writers—especially ones like Newsome—all the more important. Her work could help the show avoid clichés and offer something that’s sincere without being stuffy, modern without being hollow. After all, Trek has always been about more than starships and phasers. It’s about people—flawed, curious, evolving—and their place in a larger cosmos.
Still, some fans won’t be swayed until they see it for themselves. They remember the tonal dissonance of shows that tried to do too much or cater to too many. They want Trek to be Trek. Until Starfleet Academy airs, the jury’s out on whether Newsome will help or hinder that mission.
