Summary

  • Hero shooters are evolving, but oversaturation in the market is causing the genre to lose its appeal.
  • Single-player games like Borderlands, Gears of War, and Mass Effect 2 offer diverse heroes and emphasize teamwork like hero shooters.
  • Games like Rainbow Six and Warhammer 40k: Space Marine 2 provide a rich single-player experience with a focus on teamwork and character diversity.

In 2007, Valve released Team Fortress 2, a new multiplayer game that proved to be a bigger hit than they could have realized. At the time, there wasn't really anything quite like it. Little did Gabe Newell realize he was opening the floodgates to an entire genre that would change the face of multiplayer gaming. Then there was 2016's Overwatch, a multiplayer game clearly influenced by Team Fortress 2 which built on its foundation. After Overwatch became a hit, it suddenly seemed everyone wanted in on this action. Suddenly there was also Rainbow Six: Siege, Lawbreakers, Battleborn, Gigantic, Paladins, Valorant, Apex Legends, Boundary, Concord, and Marvel Rivals. Some big franchises, such as Call of Duty, have even started experimenting with the format. The genre started to gain a reputation for an oversaturated market. What started as a creative way to bring people together turned into a jumbled mess of similar games struggling to stand out from the crowd.

Hero Shooters to try if you're not into the genre
7 Best Hero Shooter Games To Try If You Are Not Into The Genre

The hero shooter genre is absolutely huge, but what are the best ones to try if you aren't into the genre?

While the more successful hero shooters (including Team Fortress 2, which has somehow managed to outlast all of its competition) retain a dedicated fanbase, the genre has started to become something of a tired cliche. However, there are some things that still draw players to hero shooters, and some of those can be found in other formats. It may sound strange to recommend single-player games to fans of hero shooters, but there are some that have a lot of what makes a successful hero shooter work, sometimes even more so.

Obviously, it is difficult to make a perfect 1:1 comparison between a genre intended for multiplayer and a game designed with single-player in mind. However, hero shooters have two main selling points: a diverse group of characters with unique skills, and an emphasis on teamwork. The following list is structured around shooters, or at least games with shooter mechanics, that meet at least one of these two requirements.

9 Borderlands

A Series About Creative Heroes Taking on a Chaotic World

Borderlands 2
Display card tags widget
Shooter
Display card system widget
Display card community and brand rating widget Display card open critics widget Display card main info widget Display card main info widget end Display card media widget start Display card media widget end
Checkbox: control the expandable behavior of the extra info
Display card community and brand rating widget

Released
September 18, 2012
Developer(s)
Gearbox Software
Publisher(s)
2K
Platform(s)
PC, PS4, PS3, macOS, Linux, Xbox 360, Xbox One, PS Vita, Android, Switch
Genre(s)
Shooter
OpenCritic Rating
Mighty

Part of the fun of Borderlands, aside from its wacky encounters, cartoon violence, and epic gunplay, is the series' range of heroes. Each game begins with the player being asked to select from 1-6 playable characters, each of whom has a unique "action skill" they can deploy in tough situations. These can be anything from animal companions to boomerang shields to full-on mechsuits.

While characters are tailored to different playstyles, there is also room for players to experiment with how they use those playstyles through simplified skill trees and trying different weapon loadouts. The teamwork aspect of the hero shooter can also be explored with optional co-op where up to four players can team up as different characters or at least unique builds of the same one.

8 Brothers in Arms

A Series of WW2 Shooters Emphasizing Teamwork

Brothers in Arms: Road to Hill 30
Display card tags widget
Tactical
FPS
Display card system widget
Display card community and brand rating widget Display card open critics widget Display card main info widget Display card main info widget end Display card media widget start Display card media widget end
Checkbox: control the expandable behavior of the extra info
Display card community and brand rating widget

Released
November 20, 2006
Publisher(s)
Ubisoft
Platform(s)
PC, PS3, PSP, Xbox 360
Genre(s)
Tactical, FPS

WWII shooters have become something of a sub-genre of the shooter: Call of Duty, Battlefield, Medal of Honor, Day of Defeat, Wolfenstein, Sniper Elite. But the Brothers in Arms series had one thing that helped it stand out from the crowd: emphasis on squad-based combat and actual tactics. Shooters like Call of Duty may skillfully create the appearance of the player working alongside a squad, but ultimately they are doing most of the work while NPCs engage in scripted encounters.

A lot of the tactical aspect is already figured out by a commanding officer, so the player just has to follow directions. What made Brothers in Arms stand out was its decision to put the player in the role that would normally be filled by a Captain Price-type of character. This means the player can't just charge into an enemy stronghold and try to take out a bunch of them at once. They're actually expected to rely on those under their command, which can sometimes include multiple teams with different specialties. Teamwork is key to accomplishing objectives with minimal casualties.

7 Gears of War

A Series About A Team Brought Together By an Unforgiving World

Gears of War
Display card tags widget
Third-Person Shooter
Display card system widget
Display card community and brand rating widget Display card open critics widget Display card main info widget Display card main info widget end Display card media widget start Display card media widget end
Checkbox: control the expandable behavior of the extra info
Display card community and brand rating widget

Released
November 7, 2006
Developer(s)
Epic Games
Publisher(s)
Microsoft Game Studios
Platform(s)
PC, Xbox 360
Genre(s)
Third-Person Shooter

Microsoft's flagship series is well-known for its violence, its generally bleak atmosphere, and its scathing commentary on human nature. But a big theme of the series is also teamwork and comradery. The overarching story puts heavy emphasis on not only how war shapes its protagonists, but the bonds that form between them and how they support each other in such an unforgiving world.

Between that and being designed to allow both single-player and 2-4-player co-op (depending on exactly which game you're playing), Gears of War tends to follow groups of characters who work as a team. Even in single-player mode, it means having potentially life-saving backup and occasionally comes into play when the player needs to make simple tactical decisions (i.e. Which path to take when approaching an objective). This format does a lot to help draw the player into the world, especially since it provides a great framework for developing characters individually.

6 Ghost Recon

A Series About Leading a Team of Covert Operatives on Top-Secret Missions

Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon Wildlands
Display card tags widget
Shooter
Display card system widget
Display card community and brand rating widget Display card open critics widget Display card main info widget Display card main info widget end Display card media widget start Display card media widget end
Checkbox: control the expandable behavior of the extra info
Display card community and brand rating widget

Released
March 7, 2017
Developer(s)
Ubisoft
Publisher(s)
Ubisoft
Platform(s)
PC, PlayStation 4, Xbox One, Stadia
Genre(s)
Shooter
OpenCritic Rating
Fair

Ubisoft's tactical shooter series follows various members of a specialized American military unit across top-secret operations and has been known to put a lot of emphasis on teamwork. While the franchise has had its ups and downs, and experimented with more multiplayer-oriented titles like Ghost Recon Online and Breakpoint, the basic premise of most entries remains the same. Players take command of a small squad they have to rely on to complete missions.

The player, accompanied by three-to-four others at a time, can usually issue orders to some degree. This structure puts players in the position of needing to approach situations with a tactical mind. Instead of simply charging in guns blazing, or having an NPC commanding officer who gives them orders, the player character has to carefully evaluate every situation and make full use of the allies and resources they have. It can be a challenging format and one that is not likely to appeal to all players, but excellent for anyone interested in teamwork.

5 Mass Effect 2

A Game About Building a Team of Specialists For a Dangerous Mission

Mass Effect 2
Display card tags widget
Action RPG
Third-Person Shooter
Display card system widget
Display card community and brand rating widget Display card open critics widget Display card main info widget Display card main info widget end Display card media widget start Display card media widget end
Checkbox: control the expandable behavior of the extra info
Display card community and brand rating widget

Released
January 26, 2010
Developer(s)
BioWare
Publisher(s)
Electronic Arts
Platform(s)
PS3, Xbox 360, PC
Genre(s)
Action RPG, Third-Person Shooter

While it is more commonly remembered as an RPG, Mass Effect still has extensive combat sections that make use of basic shooter mechanics. While the protagonist, Shepard, is customized by the player, all three games involve them forming a party made up of characters with unique skills. However, it is Mass Effect 2 that has the biggest and most diverse range of heroes, compared to the smaller parties of 1 and 3. The main plot of the game involves Shepard putting together a team for an expedition into the mysterious Omega 4 relay.

Siege, Apex Legends, and LawBreakers
7 Hardest Hero Shooter Games, Ranked

It takes many hours of practice to be competitive in these hero shooter games, and mastering them can take years.

By 

While Shepard is the only playable character, they get to recruit up to twelve possible allies, each of whom has a distinct personality and skillset. Shepard has to constantly manage the team, which is difficult since they can only work with two people at a time, so a balancing of skills is needed. Another upside is that as a single-player game, it can do more with the characters' stories, something that in a hero shooter would be limited to a profile description, tie-in comic, cutscene, or occasional event. Their backstories actually play into the main narrative and Shepard's choices can influence their ultimate fate, including whether they survive the final mission.

4 Rainbow Six

A Series of Tactical Shooters About Counter-Terrorism

  • Pre-Siege games of the franchise

Right now, Ubisoft's iconic series about counter-terrorism is stuck in a multiplayer hero-shooter phase with Siege and the spin-off Quarantine, but this was not always the case. Before Siege, Rainbow Six games usually ran on a single-player campaign, though there were sometimes options for co-op. Some details of gameplay varied, but they ultimately came down to a basic structure. Players are cast as the commanding officer of a counter-terrorism unit, a job which by its very nature requires them to command and rely on their squad.

This was a big thing that separated Rainbow Six from the likes of Call of Duty. Players couldn't just go in guns blazing. They actually have to evaluate the situation, determine the most effective approach, and set up the team accordingly. Another fun detail was the teams themselves were remarkably diverse for an early-2000 shooter franchise, with units often being not only mixed nationality but often mixed-race and mixed-gender (even if it took until Vegas 2 to have the option for a female protagonist), which often allows them to have more personality. It is unfortunate that Ubisoft seems reluctant to do another single-player game since a story-driven game around Siege's characters could have a lot of potential.

3 Risk of Rain 2

Uniquely-Designed Heroes Battle the Elements On an Alien Planet

Risk of Rain 2
Display card tags widget
Third-Person Shooter
Roguelike
Display card system widget
Display card community and brand rating widget Display card open critics widget Display card main info widget Display card main info widget end Display card media widget start Display card media widget end
Checkbox: control the expandable behavior of the extra info
Display card community and brand rating widget

Released
September 11, 2020
Developer(s)
Hopoo Games
Publisher(s)
Gearbox Publishing
Platform(s)
Xbox One, Nintendo Switch, PC, PS4
Genre(s)
Third-Person Shooter, Roguelike
OpenCritic Rating
Mighty

Hopoo's follow-up to their 2013 hit Risk of Rain follows an astronaut trying to survive on an alien planet, combining roguelike mechanics and a few details long-time hero shooter players might recognize. The player is given the choice of several playable survivors, with options to unlock more by progressing in the game, and a big part of the game involves locating and holding control points within a set amount of time. This kind of sounds like a hero shooter already, doesn't it?

Except it's a bit more nuanced than that. Like many games on this list, Risk of Rain 2 is designed to function in both single-player and co-op modes. There is an option for players to team up and work together, but picking out a hero and doing it solo is also a valid choice. Either way, the game is designed to challenge the players by pitting them against increasingly difficult enemies while requiring them to find a portal that leads to the next level. Surviving is the primary goal here, so the selected hero will need to make full use of their abilities, as well as any upgrades and special items found along the way.

2 Six Days in Fallujah

A Shooter About Guiding a Team Under Heavy Pressure

Six Days in Fallujah
Display card tags widget
Tactical
Shooter
Display card system widget
Display card community and brand rating widget Display card open critics widget Display card main info widget Display card main info widget end Display card media widget start Display card media widget end
Checkbox: control the expandable behavior of the extra info
Display card community and brand rating widget

Developer(s)
Highwire Games
Publisher(s)
Victura
Genre(s)
Tactical, Shooter

Highwire's ambitious shooter was designed to accurately reconstruct the real-life Second Battle of Fallujah during the War In Iraq, with the goal of avoiding the common pitfalls of other military shooters. Like many games on this list, Six Days in Fallujah can be played in either single-player or co-op, but either way, teamwork is crucial. In a war where the enemy can strike from anywhere at any time (something the developers tried to represent in the game), you can't just pick up a gun and go on a one-man-rampage like you might see with Rambo or B.J. Blazkowicz.

That's just going to get you killed at bes t. At worst, it might take a bunch of your squad mates with you. To have any chance at surviving, let alone succeeding, the player has to co-ordinate with their team, and one wrong move can have dire consequences. Six Days in Fallujah would be particularly great for fans of more intense Hero Shooters like Rainbow Six Siege, where there's a lot more pressure to approach tactfully and intelligently.

1 Warhammer 40k: Space Marine 2

A Game About Playing Adeptus Astartes And Fighting Alongside Your Brothers

Warhammer 40,000: Space Marine II
Display card tags widget
Third-Person Shooter
Hack and Slash
Display card system widget
Display card community and brand rating widget Display card open critics widget Display card main info widget Display card main info widget end Display card media widget start Display card media widget end
Checkbox: control the expandable behavior of the extra info
Display card community and brand rating widget

Released
September 9, 2024
Developer(s)
Saber Interactive
Publisher(s)
Focus Entertainment
Genre(s)
Third-Person Shooter, Hack and Slash

In the harsh universe of Warhammer 40k, a setting so bleak it somehow makes Alien look appealing by comparison, it's so common to see the worst brought out in everyone. One of the few remotely ethical things people can manage is loyalty to their friends and family, helping each other navigate a chaotic and frightening galaxy. This is particularly true of the Space Marines, soldiers of the Imperium of Man who regard each other as brothers-in-arms. This is naturally a big theme in Saber's follow-up to the 2011 cult classic.

Space Marine 2 follows protagonist Demetrian Titus and his space marine buddies Chairon and Gadriel as they battle a Tyranid invasion. Similar to Gears of War (which was probably a big influence on its gameplay), the game can be played either in single-player or co-op with up to two other players. Either way, teamwork is a big part of the game. Titus has to rely on his allies to have his back and fight alongside him, and having that backup can be quite valuable when a carnifex or neurothrope decides to show up.

Official renders of Venom and Loki from Marvel Rivals on top of an official screenshot from one of the game's maps
How Marvel Rivals Subverts Typical Hero Shooter Archetypes

Marvel Rivals takes a unique approach to character design that subverts classic archetypes, and helps the game feel fresh compared to its competition.