When Persona 3 Reload launched without the option to play as the Female Protagonist, many longtime fans expressed disappointment. For years, Kotone Shiomi had stood as one of the few alternate protagonists in the series, offering fresh perspective, tone, and player agency in Persona 3 Portable. Her absence from the remake was felt deeply, especially as Atlus made strides toward inclusivity in other areas.
A remake of Persona 4, a game where the player character has traditionally lacked strong emotional depth or dialogue, could offer Atlus the perfect opportunity to pivot. Instead of revisiting Kotone, a Persona 4 Remake could go a step further by creating an entirely new Female Protagonist from scratch. This move wouldn’t just course-correct P3R’s exclusion, but could enrich the world of Persona 4 in a way that feels fresh while honoring the original's structure.
The Best Gameplay Improvement a Persona 4 Remake Could Bring is Obvious
The rumored Persona 4 remake could improve upon its source material by adding one feature that was introduced in Persona 3 Reload.
A Persona 4 Remake Could Add a Female Protagonist
The biggest change a female protagonist could bring to Persona 4 would be tonal. Whereas Yu Narukami (the canon name for Persona 4's male protagonist) is typically portrayed as cool and emotionally subdued, a female protagonist could embody a more expressive personality. Drawing inspiration from Kotone’s lighter, more sociable demeanor compared to Makoto Yuki, the remake’s new lead might create a stronger emotional contrast to the mystery-heavy narrative.
Take, for example, scenes involving the Investigation Team’s group dynamics. The lighthearted banter between Yosuke, Chie, and the protagonist often hinges on male friendships and a sense of unspoken bro-code. A female protagonist could shift this chemistry. Instead of locker room jokes and casual jabs, the new interactions might highlight different anxieties or forms of bonding, such as Chie finding a new best friend in the protagonist, or Yukiko feeling more comfortable sharing her insecurities. These aren't just cosmetic changes; they alter the player's lens on the entire story.
Persona 3 Portable’s use of color palettes and music cues were different depending on the protagonist’s gender. A similar aesthetic shift in a Persona 4 remake could go a long way in distinguishing both routes.
How a Persona 4 FemC Would Change Social Link Paths
The addition of a female protagonist would significantly rework Persona 4's Social Links, particularly the romantic ones. In Persona 3 Portable, Kotone’s romantic options spanned from core male characters to a plot-altering arc with Shinjiro. These options expanded character development across the board, sometimes letting players see emotional sides of characters previously unexplored.
If a Persona 4 remake follows suit, the female protagonist could open up romance paths with characters like Kanji, who has long been a subject of discussion due to his struggle with gender expression and identity. A romantic arc between him and a female protagonist could allow for sensitive storytelling that doesn't rely on punchlines or ambiguity.
Similarly, the popular female characters, like Yosuke or Naoto, could respond differently depending on who the player is. A Social Link where the female protagonist interacts with Naoto during her moments of self-doubt would be greatly altered, for instance. Rather than Naoto’s path being about "becoming more feminine" for a male MC, it could shift toward self-acceptance from the perspective of a peer, not a suitor with specific expectations.
Naoto's storyline in the original version had the potential to challenge gender norms, but ultimately leaned conservative. A female-led narrative might allow that arc to reach a more progressive resolution.
A Persona 4 Remake FemC Could Affect Endgame
There’s also room to explore alternate emotional weight in the game’s final act. Persona 4 is known for its multiple endings and twists, with major events happening throughout November, December, and January depending on player choice. A female protagonist could offer alternate reactions or even drive subtly different outcomes. Her relationships with the team, the bond with Teddie or Nanako, and even the resolution with Adachi could all take on new tones.
For example, if the female protagonist were written with more overt emotional vulnerability or assertiveness, her final confrontation with the true antagonist might carry different narrative implications. While Persona 4's protagonist typically plays the role of the reserved detective who unravels the mystery, the female protagonist could embody a more outspoken sense of justice.
This wouldn’t necessarily mean diverging story paths—but rather, a tonal pendulum swing. Where Persona 3 Reload leaned into familiarity, a Persona 4 remake has the opportunity to introduce flexibility, emotional range, and deeper player choice without betraying the original plot structure.
Persona 4's Rumored Remake Should Borrow One Trick From Metaphor: ReFantazio
A potential Persona 4 remake could be set to evolve in an unexpected way by learning from Metaphor: ReFantazio’s narrative approach.
A Persona 4 FemC Could Broaden the Series
Introducing a female protagonist into Persona 4 wouldn’t just improve representation; it would help future-proof the series. The demand for diverse character options has only increased since the days of Persona 3 Portable. Having two protagonists available not only meets modern player expectations, it also invites a wider range of fans to connect with the narrative on their terms.
This is especially critical for a franchise where player identity is tied to interpersonal relationships. Allowing players to see themselves in the lead role, regardless of gender, can heighten investment, deepen storytelling, and invite multiple playthroughs. More importantly, it helps Persona grow into a franchise that listens to its community instead of just honoring longtime traditions.
Atlus has shown that it's willing to innovate within remakes, if not always in the right ways. With Persona 3 Reload setting the tone for visual and mechanical updates, Persona 4 Remake has a rare chance to lead with heart. Adding a new female protagonist wouldn’t just be fan service; it could become the emotional centerpiece of a remake that actually feels worth revisiting.
-
OpenCritic Reviews
- Top Critic Avg: 88 /100 Critics Rec: 95%
WHERE TO PLAY
- Genre(s)
- JRPG
