Some games just appear quietly and build a dedicated following over time. Others, however, suffer the fate of being declared groundbreaking months before they even launch. The games on this list aren't bad, far from it. Many are actually considered modern classics. But the expectations surrounding them were so incredibly high that no amount of polish could have fully delivered on every single promise.
This list is a celebration of seven ambitious titles that aimed big, delivered something good, but ultimately became as famous for the conversations around them as for the games themselves.
Spore
The Game That Promised A Universe
- ESRB
- E10+ For Everyone 10+ due to Animated Blood, Comic Mischief, Fantasy Violence
- Developer(s)
- Maxis
- Genre(s)
- Life Simulation
Will Wright’s Spore was introduced as an evolution simulator where players could guide a species from a single-cell organism to a spacefaring civilization. The ambition was truly staggering. Each stage featured unique mechanics, and the freedom to create was a massive part of its marketing appeal. When it launched, players received a charming toybox of creative tools, but the simplified gameplay left many feeling a bit underwhelmed, wanting more depth.
Even with that, Spore was fun in its own way. Designing odd, unbalanced creatures and watching them awkwardly stumble into battle had a certain chaotic charm. The galaxy stage was expansive, and players still look back on it fondly as one of gaming’s boldest experiments.
Cyberpunk 2077
Night City’s Rough First Impression
Cyberpunk 2077 is an open-world action-adventure from the creators of The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt, CD Projekt Red.
Set in Night City, a megalopolis obsessed with power, glamour and body modification, you play as V, a mercenary outlaw going after a one-of-a-kind implant that is the key to immortality.
Upgraded with next-gen in mind and featuring free additional content, customize your character and playstyle as you take on jobs, build a reputation, and unlock upgrades.
The relationships you forge and the choices you make will shape the story and the world around you. Legends are made here. What will yours be?
- ESRB
- M for Mature: Blood and Gore, Intense Violence, Nudity, Strong Language, Strong Sexual Content, Use of Drugs and Alcohol
- Developer(s)
- CD Projekt Red
Few games have generated as much buzz as Cyberpunk 2077. CD Projekt Red’s marketing made Night City seem alive and endlessly reactive. Players anticipated an RPG where every choice profoundly reshaped the narrative. What they got at launch was a visually stunning but very buggy experience, especially on last-gen consoles, which quickly dominated gaming discussions.
But over the course of time, through patches and expansions, Cyberpunk 2077 has evolved into the game fans initially hoped for. Phantom Liberty, in particular, brought it closer to the masterpiece people had imagined. Night City remains one of the most detailed open worlds ever created, even if its arrival was far rockier than anyone could have predicted. It really turned things around.
Watch Dogs
When The Graphics Sold The Dream
Play as Aiden Pearce, a brilliant hacker, whose criminal past led to a violent family tragedy. Now on the hunt for those who hurt your family, monitor and hack all who surround you by manipulating everything connected to the city’s network. Access omnipresent security cameras, download personal information to locate a target, control traffic lights and public transportation to stop the enemy. Use the city of Chicago as your ultimate weapon and exact your own style of revenge.
- ESRB
- M For Mature // Blood, Game Experience May Change During Online Play, Intense Violence, Nudity, Strong Language, Strong Sexual Content, Use of Drugs and Alcohol
- Genre(s)
- Open-World, Action, Adventure
Watch Dogs was Ubisoft’s new IP, intended to usher in the next generation of consoles. Its E3 2012 reveal captivated audiences with cinematic visuals and a concept that transformed Chicago into a hacking playground. Although the final product still looked good, the visual downgrade and predictable mission design left fans wanting more.
It wasn't a failure, though. Aiden Pearce’s story of revenge, combined with the ability to control traffic lights and security systems, created some memorable sandbox moments. Later sequels refined the formula, but the first game is remembered as the moment players collectively learned to be cautious about flashy E3 reveals.
Fable
Planting Seeds Of Hype
Fable is an RPG developed by Playground Games and published by Microsoft. Set in Albion, the game challenges players to define what it means to be a hero.
- Developer(s)
- Playground Games
- Genre(s)
- Action RPG, Adventure
Fable was going to allow players to plant acorns that grew into trees and shape an entire kingdom. While many of those grand promises never made it into the final game, what players received was a funny, heartfelt RPG with genuine moral choice systems and a distinct personality.
Although Lionhead Studios could not deliver every feature they teased but they certainly gave players something memorable. Becoming a horned demon or a halo-wearing saint was enough to keep fans hooked, and Fable still holds a special place in RPG history.
The Order: 1886
Gorgeous But Brief
The Order: 1886™ introduces players to a unique vision of Victorian-Era London where Man uses advanced technology to battle a powerful and ancient foe. As Galahad, a member of an elite order of Knights, join a centuries-old war against a powerful threat that will determine the course of history forever in this intense third-person action-adventure shooter, available exclusively on the PlayStation®4 system.
Assume the role of Galahad, one of the most experienced Knights of The Order, and enter a unique vision of Victorian-Era London that fuses real historical figures and events with new twists on familiar myths and legends
Conflict rages in this 19th century London between enemies new and old. Rebels declare all-out war on The Order and the police state they represent, while mankind’s true enemy, a powerful and ancient foe known as Half-breeds grows in strength and numbers in and around the city.
Wield cutting-edge weapons and gadgets like the Arc Gun, Thermite Rifle, and Monocular, as you struggle to maintain peace and order amidst the growing civil unrest and Half-breed threat against humankind.
- ESRB
- M For Mature 17+ due to Blood and Gore, Intense Violence, Nudity, Sexual Content, Strong Language
- Developer(s)
- Ready at Dawn
- Genre(s)
- Third-Person Shooter
When The Order: 1886 was first shown, its cinematic visuals and steampunk London setting seemed poised to revolutionize narrative-driven shooters. What players got was one of the best-looking games of its era. But it offered only a few hours of linear gameplay and not much replay value.
8 Best Action-Adventure Video Game Franchises, Ranked
These iconic video game franchises are well-known for releasing the best action-adventure games.
Despite the criticism, it wasn't without merit. The world-building was excellent, the gunplay satisfying, and it left many players wishing for a sequel. Its struggle was primarily with expectations. Fans anticipated a grand, lengthy epic. What they received was closer to an interactive movie, and that mismatch ultimately defined its legacy.
The Elder Scrolls 4: Oblivion
Hype Can Be A Double-Edged Sword
The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion Game of the Year Edition presents one of the best RPGs of all time like never before. Step inside the most richly detailed and vibrant game-world ever created. With a powerful combination of freeform gameplay and unprecedented graphics, you can unravel the main quest at your own pace or explore the vast world and find your own challenges. Also included in the Game of the Year edition are Knights of the Nine and the Shivering Isles expansion, adding new and unique quests and content to the already massive world of Oblivion. See why critics called Oblivion the Best Game of 2006.
When Oblivion was announced, the promise of radiant AI and fully voiced NPCs sent expectations through the roof. It was advertised everywhere and touted as one of the first games that truly showcased what the Xbox 360 and PC hardware could achieve, with lush forests and sprawling dungeons. The reality was a bit messier, though, featuring uncanny NPC faces and AI that often behaved amusingly rather than realistically.
Despite these quirks, Oblivion became a genre-defining RPG and a significant leap forward from Morrowind. Cyrodiil felt like a living, breathing world, and the Shivering Isles expansion remains a fan favorite. Its initial overhype just meant that players expected perfection, and perfection in an open-world RPG was always going to be an unrealistic goal.
No Man's Sky
A True Redemption Arc
Lose yourself in a vast sci-fi odyssey as you explore a near-infinite, procedurally generated universe. Set out from the edge of the Euclid galaxy and carve out your own interstellar existence in a vast universe teeming with life, danger and near-endless mystery. No Man's Sky is a hugely-ambitious, heavily-stylised, sci-fi adventure that spans entire galaxies all brought to life with procedural generation. Travel through an endless array of increasingly diverse and dangerous star systems, prospecting for rare materials, trading with alien life, populate planets and searching for clues to the meaning of the universe's mysterious existence. How you survive is up to you. Assemble entire fleets of dreadnought-class freighters and tear across the universe; build sprawling habitable bases across planet surfaces, beneath the ground or under the ocean; buy and upgrade your own weapons and star ships and do battle with outlaw space pirates, hostile alien fauna or the mysterious sentinel fleets. The universe is yours to explore - trillions upon trillions of planets, waiting to be discovered.
- ESRB
- T for Teen: Fantasy Violence, Animated Blood
- Developer(s)
- Hello Games
Hello Games’ No Man’s Sky is the prime example of prerelease overhype. Its trailers promised infinite vibrant worlds filled with diverse wildlife and multiplayer encounters. At launch, players discovered that while the universe was vast, its planets often felt empty and somewhat repetitive.
Since then, No Man’s Sky has become one of the best comeback stories in gaming. Years of free updates have added multiplayer, base building, giant freighters, and story-driven expeditions. Today, it feels much closer to the dream that was initially pitched, proving that sometimes an overhyped launch can indeed be the beginning of something truly great.
Best No Man's Sky Updates Ever
Relive the evolution of No Man's Sky through its most impactful updates. From co-op multiplayer to corvettes and beyond.