Summary
- Rookie cards in MLB The Show 25 offer unique potential and value for Diamond Dynasty lineups.
- Highlighted rookies like Holliday, Anthony, and Jenkins excel in various skills, from speed to power hitting.
- Rookies like Campbell, Crews, and Painter show promise for future growth, making them valuable long-term assets.
Players can look to the future of baseball and see the upcoming stars of the sport with the Rookie cards in MLB The Show 25. Many of the cards come with unique potential that might not be seen in some of the more famous players, making them valuable additions to any lineup in Diamond Dynasty.
This list aims to highlight some of the best Rookie cards currently available, based on their in-game performances and overall impact. From hard hitters, fantastic fielders to dominating defenses, there will be something for every player. Fans may even see some of these stars rise up the ranks in years to come.
10 Jackson Holliday – Orioles 2B
Reliable Contact Hitter
- OVR: 73
- Speed: 90
- Price: 120
Holliday has solid contact ratings and speed, making him a reliable option. His potential in the present and the future can be seen in his defensive attributes, which ensure stability in the infield.
However, he is not the most powerful hitter, so he makes up for that with his consistency and speed. He will be helpful to players who want to focus on small ball strategies. He has real potential to grow in the sport, which only adds to his appeal for players who are looking at long-term gameplay.
9 Roman Anthony – Red Sox CF
Speedy Defensive Pick
- OVR: 87
- Control L: 95
- Availability: Pipeline Collection
Anthony excels in athleticism and defensive prowess, which is unique for a rookie. He is a great pick for center field, because of his speed and fielding attributes. He is a reliable hitter, but his contact ratings are decent and not a high level like some others on the list.
The combination of speed and defense makes Anthony the perfect leadoff hitter or a defensive replacement. He has a huge potential to grow, and that development should be watched by all players.
8 Walker Jenkins – Twins CF
Built For The Middle Lineup
- OVR: 87
- Accuracy: 79
- Availability: Pipeline Program
Jenkins is the epitome of power hitting, and for a rookie, his power ratings and contact are solid, making him a threat when he is at the plate. He might not be much of a fielder, with his attributes in those areas being average, but his offensive potential is significant to any lineup.
When placed in the middle of the batting order, Jenkins can utilize his power to drive in runs. While he might not be top of the table just yet, players will start to see more value in his development over time.
7 Kristian Campbell – Red Sox 2B
Versatile Utility Option
- OVR: 87
- Control R: 84
- Price: 9100
Campbell showcases real potential and versatility with his Rookie card. His ability to play multiple positions and solid contact ratings make him a flexible option and pick for any kind of lineup players are looking to have, if they can spare the stubs.
Adaptability is something a lot of players look for in their Diamond Dynasty playthroughs, and Campbell is a valuable player with that in mind. He has real potential for growth in both defensive and offensive areas and could be the key asset for lineups as he progresses.
6 Dylan Crews – Nationals RF
The Balanced Rookie
- OVR: 78
- Reach: 99
- Price: 190
Crews is an overall well-rounded player, with his Rookie card highlighting his balanced skill set, perfect for any lineup in Diamond Dynasty. His contact and power ratings are good, but he really shines with his fielding attributes.
MLB The Show 25: How To Change Position In RTTS
If your Road to the Show player hasn't found the right fit, it might be time to change position in MLB The Show 25.
One of the best middle grounds for a player’s lineup, Crews has versatility that will allow him to jump into any role a player sees fit. He will be a reliable part of the team no matter where he is placed, and those balanced attributes will come in handy.
5 Jackson Jobe – Tigers SP
The Reliable Starter
- OVR 86
- Control: 85
- Availability: Team Affinity
Jobe has high-class pitching potential with his Rookie card. With break ratings and that high velocity, he is a presence that players will not forget on the mound. He has decent control too, making him a great pick to be a reliable and needed starting pitcher, especially as he can be picked up in Team Affinity.
No matter what rotation a player has, Jobe’s pitching skills make him a great addition to the lineup. As he develops his skills over time, his effectiveness in matches and overall values are going to increase for sure.
4 Andrew Painter – Phillies SP
A Future Ace
- OVR: 87
- Velocity: 96
- Price: 7000
Painter’s Rookie card shows his huge potential to become a future ace. His break ratings and impressive velocity show him to be a dominant force. For players who are looking for longevity in games, Painter’s solid control and stamina could be the way to go.
His great pitching capabilities will make Painter a cornerstone for any rotation. He is a rising star and someone players should definitely look out for, as he will only grow as an asset as he develops.
3 Elly De La Cruz – Reds SS
Speedster Shortstop
- OVR: 90
- Speed: 99
- Available: Takeover Program
De La Cruz’s Rookie card highlights his star qualities, including his excellent speed and athleticism. His combination of decent contact ratings and high speed make him a threat on the field. His additional skills in fielding attributes are also solid, which would make him a reliable shortstop too.
MLB The Show 25: How To Upload a Face Scan in RTTS
Find out how to upload a face scan and truly personalize your RTTS player in MLB The Show 25.
His speed and agility make him an ideal leadoff hitter. His card is a must for many players looking for the right kind of rookie for their lineup, and De La Cruz will not disappoint.
2 Gunnar Henderson – Orioles SS
Middle Order Power
- OVR: 85
- Quirks: Homebody, Unfazed, Fighter
- Price: 4500
Henderson’s power-hitting capabilities make him a rookie card players will not want to miss out on. He has a formidable presence at the plate, due to his high-power ratings and solid contact. Players can also use him as a reliable third baseman due to his fielding attributes being decent too.
Henderson just misses out on the top spot, but his offensive skills make him a key pick for players looking to change up their middle batting order or a new shortstop. Long-term gameplay will be a little easier with him in the lineup.
1 Paul Skenes – Pirates SP
Dominant Rookie Pitcher
- OVR: 88
- Quirk: Outlier 1
- Price: 65000
Skene is one of the most dominant forces on the mound as a rookie. He has exceptional velocity and break ratings, and has to take this top spot for being a high-tier starting pitcher. His skills of control and stamina make sure he will remain effective throughout games, no matter what happens.
His pitching abilities as a rookie are enough for players to know he is a must-have for any rotation they have. Skene has a lot of room for growth too, so he is worth holding on to, as an asset in both short-term and long-term gameplay in Diamond Dynasty.
- Released
- March 18, 2025
- Developer(s)
- San Diego Studio
- Publisher(s)
- Sony Interactive Entertainment
- Franchise
- MLB The Show
WHERE TO PLAY
- Genre(s)
- Sports
- Platform(s)
- Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 5, Xbox Series S, Xbox Series X
