Summary

  • Thor has been bested by formidable characters like Hulk, Hercules, and even Superman in comic book history.
  • Hercules drained Thor's power, Red Hulk defied Mjolnir's enchantment, and Scarlet Witch overpowered the god.
  • Unexpectedly, even Squirrel Girl and Mantis have managed to defeat the mighty Thor in various comic storylines within the Marvel universe.

Thor is widely regarded as one of the strongest characters in the Marvel Comics universe. As one of the most famous members of the Avengers, the character has reached incredible heights in many different comic book timelines. Of course, that's to be expected of a character who is a superpowered god that possesses the power of summoning lightning.

A picture of Alternate Versions Of Thor
Marvel: 10 Strongest Versions Of Thor, Ranked

Thor is obviously one of the strongest heroes in the Marvel roster, but these versions of Thor are on another level.

2

However, Thor hasn't always won every fight he's gotten himself into. He's faced opponents several times, whether they be heroic allies or mastermind supervillains, who have bested him in combat, one way or another. These ten characters in Marvel Comics history may even surprise readers when they find out that they have won against the mighty Thor.

10 Hercules

Thor's Rival Has Brought Greece-d Lightning

thor fighting hercules

Aliases

Hercules Panhellios, Herakles, Herc, Defender of Olympus, Giant-Killer, Prince of Power

Powers

Godlike strength, superhuman speed, invulnerability, regeneration, immortality

Team Affiliations

Gods of War, Avengers, Secret Avengers, Heroes for Hire, Defenders, Argonauts

Portrayed in the MCU By

Brett Goldstein (Thor: Love & Thunder)

When They Fought Thor

Thor Vol. 1, #126

Hercules and Thor have been rivals throughout their comic book histories, given their numerous similarities as children of pantheonic leaders (Zeus and Odin, respectively). In fact, Hercules' original introduction in the comics was in a joint issue with Thor, though their fight in that issue was halted by Zeus with no winner.

However, in issue #126 of Thor's very first solo run, Thor and Hercules rematch when they're fighting over Jane Foster's love. It's an evenly-matched fight, but Thor's power is suddenly drained by Odin, letting Hercules get the upper hand. As a result of defeating Thor publicly, Hercules is swarmed by fans and Hollywood agents, while Thor is able to keep the girl.

9 The Hulk

Thor Often Scraps With His Fellow Avenger

Hulk fighting Thor

Aliases

Bruce Banner, Green Goliath

Powers

Gamma physiology, transformation, super-strength, super-durability, healing factor, telepathic resistance

Team Affiliations

Avengers, Illuminati, S.H.I.E.L.D., Defenders, New Hulkbusters, New Fantastic Four

Portrayed in the MCU By

Mark Ruffalo (The Avengers-onward), Edward Norton (The Incredible Hulk)

When They Fought Thor

Thor Vol. 1, #385

Hulk and Thor have fought plenty of times in their Marvel Comics pasts, as perhaps the most combative members of the Avengers. In the very first Avengers comic, Loki mind-controls Hulk into fighting Thor, only for Thor and Hulk to team up and defeat Loki. However, the two get to fight for real in issue #385 of Thor's original comic book run.

Marvel-12-Surprising-Characters-Who-Have-Beaten-the-Hulk
Marvel: 27 Surprising Characters Who Have Beaten The Hulk

Believe it or not, these well-known characters have managed to beat the Hulk.

Thor has the upper hand against Hulk at first until Hulk threatens an innocent woman so Thor abandons Mjolnir and fights him for real. Thor struggles to defeat Hulk without his hammer and is eventually beaten into submission as the Hulk leaves. Thor realizes it's better to let his fellow Avenger go free, given the destruction caused in the wake of the battle.

8 Red Hulk

A Much Tougher Hulk Surprises Even Thor

Red Hulk catching Thor's hammer

Aliases

Thaddeus Ross, Thunderbolt,

Powers

Gamma physiology, conscious transformation, super-strength, healing factor, energy absorption

Team Affiliations

Power Elite, Hulkbusters, Avengers, Thunderbolts

Portrayed in the MCU By

Harrison Ford (Captain America: New World Order-onward), William Hurt (The Incredible Hulk-Black Widow)

When They Fought Thor

Hulk Vol. 2, #5

Thaddeus "Thunderbolt" Ross is notorious for turning himself into the Red Hulk after his daughter is killed by Abomination. What sets Ross' Red Hulk apart from Banner is that he's able to transform consciously, rather than Bruce's uncontrollable transformations. In issue #5 of this comic book series, Red Hulk has just defeated Banner when Thor confronts him.

This fight becomes one of Thor's toughest matches, as Red Hulk is able to resist a lot of Thor's strongest attacks. Red Hulk is even able to lift Thor into the air while the thunder god is holding Mjolnir, a loophole to the enchantment that only the worthy can lift. In the end, Red Hulk throws Thor (and Mjolnir) on the moon and leaves him in the moon dust.

7 Scarlet Witch

Few Avengers Can Overcome Wanda's Magic

Wanda using her powers to stop Thor

Aliases

Wanda Maximoff, Living Darkhold, Emperor of Magic

Powers

Witchcraft, Chaos magic, clairvoyance, energy manipulation, flight, reality warping, resurrection, telepathy, teleportation

Team Affiliations

Avengers, West Coast Avengers, Secret Defenders, Brotherhood of Evil Mutants

Portrayed in the MCU By

Elizabeth Olsen (Captain America: The Winter Soldier-onward)

When They Fought Thor

Uncanny Avengers Vol. 1, #4

It may not be so surprising to see Scarlet Witch at odds with another Avenger, given the sorceress' tendency to toe the line between hero and villain. However, despite Marvel Comics fans online insisting that Wanda isn't strong enough to defeat Thor, this comic book from 2013 proved otherwise when Thor is mind-controlled by the Red Skull.

While Scarlet Witch wasn't alone in facing off against this Thor, as she had Avengers like Captain America and Havoc. However, in this issue, she's able to finally defeat Thor by using Chaos magic to send the Norse god into space. For what it's worth, Elizabeth Olsen seems to agree that Wanda is more powerful than Thor even in the MCU.

6 She-Hulk

Thor's Part-Time Lover, Part-Time Opponent

She-Hulk fighting Thor

Aliases

Jennifer Walters, Hulkette, Shulk

Powers

Gamma physiology, transformation, super-strength, body-switching

Team Affiliations

Avengers, Fantastic Four, Lady Liberators, Defenders, Heroes for Hire, Hulkbusters

Portrayed in the MCU By

Tatiana Maslany (She-Hulk: Attorney-at-Law)

When They Fought Thor

Avengers Vol. 1, #296-297

At this point, it seems like Thor actually struggles to fare well against all kinds of Hulks. Jennifer Walters is no exception, given that the lawyer-turned-superhero has tended to do lots of incredible things in the comics, whether it's defeating villains like Psycho-Man or breaking the fourth wall and intimidating the comic book writers.

She-Hulk on the cover of her 2022 comic run; She-Hulk after transforming in an Avengers comic; Tatiana Maslany as She-Hulk in Ep 1 of
Marvel: 8 Impressive Feats She-Hulk Pulls Off In The Comics

She-Hulk has managed to pull off some incredible feats. Here are her most impressive feats from the comics.

However, in these two Avengers comics, Jen is even able to defeat her fellow Avengers, Thor and Black Knight, while mind-controlled by Dr. Druid (who is ultimately also being controlled by Ravonna Renslayer). Upon learning what she did after being freed, Jen departs from the Avengers to confront her guilt at fighting her allies.

5 Ghost Rider

Thor Can't Overcome The Spirit Of Vengeance

Ghost Rider fighting Thor

Aliases

Johnny Blaze, Brimstone Avenger, Spirit of Vengeance, Bonehead

Powers

Transformation, super-strength, invulnerability, regeneration, hellfire generation, magic, soul manipulation, penance stare

Team Affiliations

Midnight Sons, Savage Avengers, Thunderbolts, Defenders

Portrayed in the MCU By

Gabriel Luna (Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D), Nicolas Cage (Ghost Rider-Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance)

When They Fought Thor

Avengers Vol. 1, #214

Ghost Rider is often underestimated as a Marvel hero, given that he usually runs in different circles than Thor and the other Avengers. However, issue #214 of the original Avengers series saw Johnny Blaze possessed by the demon Zarathos, causing him to go on a violent tirade that alerts the Avengers, who show up to stop him.

Unfortunately, Ghost Rider is no easy fight for the superhero team, consisting of Captain America, Thor, Tigra, The Wasp, and Iron Man. While Thor initially gets the best of Ghost Rider, the spirit of vengeance is able to ride Mjolnir and crash into Thor, knocking him out and escaping as the Avengers regroup from their embarrassing defeat.

4 Mantis

Not Even A God Can Resist Her Powers

Mantis putting Thor to sleep

Aliases

Brandt, Celestial Madonna

Powers

Empathy, telepathy, astral projection, precognition, regeneration

Team Affiliations

Guardians of the Galaxy, Avengers, Knowhere Corps

Portrayed in the MCU By

Pom Klementieff

When They Fought Thor

Avengers Vol. 1 #114 & #123

For some, hearing that a villain with few powers like Mantis has defeated Thor may come as a shock. However, MCU fans know how underestimated she is, given that Mantis was nearly able to incapacitate Thanos in Avengers: Infinity War. She's done similar tricks against the god of Thunder, as seen in several Avengers issues from the early 1970's.

In issue #114, Mantis and Swordsman join the Avengers, though their allying is a ploy from the Lion God to kill Black Panther. During the ensuing fight, Mantis and Swordsman initially side with the Lion God and are able to best Thor with Mantis putting him to sleep. Issues later, she does the same in another confrontation with the Avengers.

3 Beta Ray Bill

A Thor Copycat Gets The Best Of The Hero

Beta Ray Bill fighting Thor

Aliases

Godhunter, Champion of Korbin, Thor

Powers

Super-strength, super-speed, healing factor

Team Affiliations

Guardians of the Galaxy, Omega Flight, Annihilators, Thor Corps

Portrayed in the MCU By

N/A

When They Fought Thor

Thor Vol. 1, #337 & #338

Beta Ray Bill is designed to be Thor's biggest rival, as a Korbinite warrior who is surprisingly revealed to be worthy of Mjolnir. After being sent by Nick Fury to investigate a rogue spaceship, Thor is fought by Beta Ray Bill in the character's debut appearance, a fight which results in Thor losing Mjolnir, and Beta Ray Bill claiming it as a spoil of war.

strongest video game thor featured image
10 Strongest Versions Of Thor In Video Games, Ranked

The Norse god Thor has appeared in many video games throughout the years, and these are his strongest versions, ranked by power.

Issues later, Odin demands that the two rematch for the right to keep the hammer, and this time, Beta Ray Bill wins again, claiming the hammer as his. However, he returned it to Thor anyway and got himself a new weapon, Stormbreaker, and later became an ally to Thor and other Asgardians like Sif, even joining a hammer-wielding superhero team, the Thor Corps.

2 Squirrel Girl

She's Overpowered, Even By Marvel's Standards

Squirrel Girl wearing Thor's armor

Aliases

Doreen Green, Lady Crimepocalypse, The Slayer of All That Breathes

Powers

Squirrel powers, super-strength, healing factor

Team Affiliations

New Avengers, S.H.I.E.L.D., Great Lakes Avengers

Portrayed in the MCU By

Milana Vayntrub (Cancelled New Warriors series)

When They Fought Thor

Unbeatable Squirrel Girl Beats Up the Marvel Universe, #1

Squirrel Girl has been shown to be incredibly overpowered for comedic purposes. The superhero fluent in squirrel language has defeated the likes of Thanos, Wolverine, and Doctor Doom, so fighting and winning against a character like Thor should be expected at this point.

In the annual comic, Unbeatable Squirrel Girl Beats Up the Marvel Universe, Doreen Green is confronted with evil clones of the entire Marvel universe. She's even been shown to be worthy of lifting Mjolnir, a feat only few Marvel heroes can boast about. In fact, the only hero that Doreen has actually struggled to defeat is, funnily enough, a variant of herself.

1 Superman

He's Not Even From Marvel, But He Still Beat Thor

Superman catching Thor's hammer

Aliases

Kal-El, Clark Kent, God of Strength

Powers

Kryptonian physiology, super-strength, super-speed, super-vision, heat vision, flight, invulnerability, teleportation

Team Affiliations

Justice League, Sinestro Corps, SuperCorp, The Authority, Legion of Super-Heroes

Portrayed in the DCEU By

Henry Cavill (Man of Steel-Black Adam), Nicolas Cage (The Flash), David Corenswet (Superman-onward)

When They Fought Thor

JLA/Avengers, #2

It shouldn't be a surprise that one of the strongest superheroes ever created has defeated Thor, but it might be simply due to the fact that Marvel and DC have very rarely crossed over. The four-issue miniseries JLA/Avengers featured a lot of fights between characters from Marvel and DC, one of the most anticipated being Thor's spat with Superman in issue #2.

In all fairness, the fight between the two pushed both heroes to their limits, as Superman struggled to counter Thor's hammer. However, Superman is able to best the Avenger before declaring that it was the hardest fight of his life. Still, this was one time and was a product of storytelling choices, so maybe Thor can defeat Superman under a different writer's watch.

Superman Surprising Defeats
DC: 8 Surprising Characters Who Have Beaten Superman

Superman is known as one of the most unbeatable superheroes in either Marvel or DC, but some surprising names have victories over the Man of Steel.