It seems like just about every significant horror IP is being remade or considered for a remake in the modern age. Generally speaking, horror seems to be as big as ever, with even family-friendly Nintendo seemingly dipping its toes back into the genre with the recently revealed, enigmatic Emio. But Nintendo ought not to stop there, as an oft-overlooked classic GameCube title by the name of Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem would be perfect for the remake treatment.
Capcom may be leading the charge with remakes of classic Resident Evil games, but it's far from the only game company engaging in this practice. EA recently dropped the much-lauded Dead Space remake, Konami is trying its hand with the Silent Hill 2 remake, and THQ Nordic brought Alone in the Dark back into the mainstream with a star-studded hard reboot earlier this year. All of this is to say that, while these franchises began their lives on older consoles like the first PlayStation, and underwent a number of less-successful permutations over the years, they haven't been left behind. Eternal Darkness is more than deserving of a similar reprisal.
The Mortuary Assistant Could Predict the Success of an Eternal Darkness Revival
Rising to notoriety thanks to streamers and YouTubers, The Mortuary Assistant could lay the groundwork for a revival of Eternal Darkness.
A Modern Remake of Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem Has a Lot of Potential
Eternal Darkness Was One of the Most Unique GameCube-Era Horror Experiences
Developed by Silicon Knights and released in 2002 as a GameCube exclusive, Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem follows several different characters over the course of 2,000 years, as they all contend with an ancient evil looking to control humankind. Eternal Darkness has a lot in common with its survival horror contemporaries, especially Resident Evil, as it hones it on features like a fixed camera angle, inventory management, and sparse enemy placement.
But it's remarkably original as well, even by modern standards. The era-hopping story, for instance, helps keep gameplay fresh, as the ancient time periods will naturally require players to master melee combat, while the more modern chapters allow for the use of firearms and other contemporary tools. Additionally, player choice impacts both narrative and gameplay, with certain puzzles, combat encounters, and story beats being altered depending on crucial decisions. These features make Eternal Darkness a surprisingly deep and dense experience with a lot of complexity and replay value.
None of these are the most iconic features of the game, though; Eternal Darkness is perhaps best remembered for its sanity meter, which will deplete whenever the player encounters new enemies. As the meter runs low, Sanity Effects will occur, and these can range from minor visual changes like a shift in camera angle all the way to major fourth-wall-breaking effects, including fake error messages that can fool players into thinking there's something wrong with their game or TV. These Sanity Effects (which Nintendo actually patented) make for an uncomfortably immersive experience, as players may question their own sanity alongside the game's protagonists.
An Eternal Darkness Remake Could Greatly Enrich Gaming's Horror Scene
As previously mentioned, the horror genre is as popular as ever in the world of gaming. However, the AAA horror scene is dangerously close to being homogenized, and some may argue that it already has been. In the wake of Capcom's Resident Evil remakes, modern horror games seem to all be taking a similar approach to their design: over-the-shoulder third-person action mixed with linear exploration and the occasional jump scare. This was one of the reasons why the Alone in the Dark reboot fell flat for many players, and it's also a big reason why so many are trepidatious about the Silent Hill 2 remake.
An Eternal Darkness remake could offer something as bold and exciting as the original. By modernizing the classic title's most iconic features, especially the Sanity Effects, horror fans could sink their teeth into a truly inventive and unsettling experience that stands apart from the sea of action-focused horror games on the market, as good as those games may be.
Eternal Darkness: Sanity’s Requiem
- Released
- June 24, 2002
WHERE TO PLAY
Eternal Darkness: Sanity’s Requiem is a Nintendo GameCube exclusive psychological horror game with heavy sanity elements. Created by Silicon Knights, this M-rated horror game sees players guide Alexandra Roivas through a spooky mansion. The game also lets players explore other time periods as other characters in order to flesh out the mysterious narrative.
- ESRB
- M For Mature 17+ due to Animated Blood and Gore, Animated Violence
- Developer(s)
- Silicon Knights
- Publisher(s)
- Nintendo
- Platform(s)
- GameCube
- Genre(s)
- Action-Adventure
- How Long To Beat
- 14 Hours
