Summary
- The horror game market is oversaturated, leaving some unique and underappreciated gems unnoticed.
- Games like Among the Sleep, Narcosis, and Visage offer new and intense experiences in horror gaming.
- Some underrated horror games like Apsulov, Maid of Sker, and Cry of Fear deserve more attention for their unique settings and gameplay.
Horror games have always been a staple of the gaming world, but ever since the early 2010s, there has been a massive boom in horror game popularity, particularly in the indie world. While that's great for horror gamers, inevitably, some games get cast aside and never get the attention they deserve, particularly in the saturated first-person horror game market.
10 Most Iconic Horror Game Protagonists, Ranked
These iconic heroes are the faces of the games they starred in.
That doesn't mean that these games should be missed. In actuality, some of the most unique experiences in all of horror gaming come from underappreciated projects that need a little love. Whether it's playing as a toddler or exploring the bottom of the deep, dark ocean, there are a lot of great first-person horror games you've probably never heard of that are worth checking out.
8 Among The Sleep
Knee-High Horror
Among the Sleep
- Released
- May 29, 2014
WHERE TO PLAY
- ESRB
- m
- Genre(s)
- Survival Horror, Action-Adventure
In the early 2010s, the horror game boom taught developers a lot, but maybe most importantly, it taught them that horror was a genre primed for experimentation and emotional storytelling. While there were certainly many Amnesia clones, there was also a slew of other projects that tried to take horror games in entirely new directions.
Among the Sleep is one of the very best experiments in this category. Instead of playing as a capable adult, the player controls a toddler. This genius move makes everything else feel scarier from a child's perspective, and the game delivers some incredibly memorable scares without a big budget.
7 Narcosis
What Lurks Below
Narcosis
- Released
- March 28, 2017
WHERE TO PLAY
Unfortunately, getting attention as an indie developer during the horror boom of the 2010s was sometimes tricky. For every smash hit like Doki Doki Literature Club, there were hundreds of games that went unfairly unnoticed and unplayed.
Narcosis was one of those games that missed finding a big audience, which is a shame, because its deep-sea setting mixed with psychological horror and a hefty dose of arachnophobia is really punchy stuff. For players who loved games like SOMA or horror games set at sea, Narcosis is the next best thing.
6 Visage
The P.T. Successor
Visage
- Released
- October 30, 2020
- ESRB
- m
- Developer(s)
- SadSquare Studio
- Genre(s)
- Horror
The removal of P.T. From all game stores was a tragedy, particularly as the short playable demo is probably one of the greatest horror games ever made, which is saying something. Yet, the fallout of the Kojima/Konami fiasco and the subsequent cancellation of Silent Hills meant a follow-up was not forthcoming.
Luckily, there were plenty of indie developers willing to take up the mantle, and Visage is the best of the lot. With a strong focus on hyper-realistic graphics, visceral first-person scares, and brilliant lighting systems, Visage is the P.T. Successor that gamers were clamoring for, one that's full of unsettling details for the keen-eyed gamer.
5 Cry Of Fear
An Underplayed Classic
Cry of Fear
- Released
- February 22, 2012
WHERE TO PLAY
- ESRB
- m
- Genre(s)
- Survival Horror, FPS
Valve is a unique company for a lot of reasons, but it's truly remarkable how many mods and fan games based on their properties are spun into brilliant games all on their own, matching and even surpassing the efforts of AAA developers. While Garry's Mod and Counter-Strike get all the glory, horror gamers need to check out Cry of Fear.
Every Half-Life Game, Ranked
Half-Life has been one of the most iconic and beloved FPS franchises for almost 30 years, but there are more games than some might know about.
Based on a mod for Half-Life, Cry of Fear is a psychologically intensive and viscerally terrifying romp through a nightmarish version of Stockholm full of creepy monsters and devilish horror set pieces. It's a rollicking good time with a lot to say about mental health, and is criminally underplayed.
4 Apsulov: End Of Gods
Odin Of The Future
Apsulov: End of Gods
- Released
- August 8, 2019
WHERE TO PLAY
- ESRB
- M for Mature 17+ // Blood and Gore, Intense Violence, Strong Language
For unclear reasons, the mid- to late-2010s, and even the early 2020s, saw a massive boom in popularity for Norse and Viking history, with a deluge of games and media taking inspiration from it dropping almost every week. Inevitably, some games would get lost in that flood, and unfortunately, Apsulov: End of Gods was one of them.
That's a shame, because Apsulov is actually unique in transposing Norse mythology, symbology, and imagery into a futuristic sci-fi horror setting, making it stand out from the crowd. Still, it never got the crowd it deserved, but for any fans of Norse-inspired games with a keen eye for folk horror, no game plays quite like Apsulov.
3 Maid Of Sker
The Welsh Get A Look In
Maid of Sker
- Released
- July 28, 2020
WHERE TO PLAY
- ESRB
- M For Mature 17+ Due to Blood and Gore, Strong Language, Violence
- Genre(s)
- Horror
Wales gets overlooked more often than it deserves. It's a country brimming with creative talent, yet it struggles to make a splash on the world stage. Wales Interactive, the developers behind Maid of Sker, made a conscious effort to change the conversation and let the gaming world take notice by setting all their games in Wales, often drawing on Welsh folklore.
While Maid of Sker may not have made the splash they were hoping for, it's still well worth playing, It's a great horror game with a unique setting (which is probably one of the best horror game hotels ever made), and makes for a great weekend game that doesn't take up too much time. Even with its short runtime, it sticks in the memory thanks to its effective sound-based scares and stunning graphical fidelity.
2 Clive Barker's Undying
Horror Fiction Makes The Jump
Clive Barker's Undying
- Released
- February 7, 2021
WHERE TO PLAY
- ESRB
- m
- Genre(s)
- Survival Horror, FPS
Horror book fans will know that Clive Barker is one of the greatest horror authors of all time. His books, and particularly his short stories, are gruesome little affairs that draw on grisly imagery and Lovecraftian elements to cement themselves in the canon of great horror literature.
8 Best Dark Fantasy Horror Games
Dark fantasy games often run parallel to horror, eschewing the magic and wonder of high fantasy for the dark and grotesque scenes in these titles.
However, Barker's success never fully translated into the world of video games. That said, Clive Barker's Undying, the most notable effort that was first released in 2001 as, ostensibly, a Doom clone, successfully translates what makes his novels great into a whole new medium. The game has a cult following, particularly for its unique story, which follows an Irish paranormal investigator, and its crunchy magic and gun-based gameplay.
1 Penumbra: Overture
The Amnesia Predecessor
Penumbra: Overture - Episode 1
- Released
- March 30, 2007
- Platform(s)
- PC
Though its reputation has become somewhat mixed since its release, Amnesia: The Dark Descent is one of the most important horror games ever made, fundamentally shifting the style of horror games that came afterwards in a way that the gaming world still feels to this day. With that much attention, it's really surprising that Frictional Games' previous effort in the Penumbra series—three episodic horror games that take players deep within strange icy caverns, hidden facilities, and dread-filled caves—remains relatively unknown despite the developer's pedigree.
With each entry, it's easy to say Frictional honed their horror craft, delivering on much of what makes Amnesia: The Dark Descent work later on, including a really eerie atmosphere. The entire Penumbra series of games is criminally underplayed and underrated, so any horror fan looking for their next terrifying experience should take notice.
8 Best Dark Fantasy Horror Games
Dark fantasy games often run parallel to horror, eschewing the magic and wonder of high fantasy for the dark and grotesque scenes in these titles.