The Penguin is proving to be one of the best comic book series of the past few years, but it isn't all that connected to the comics themselves. It's an interstitial piece between The Batman and its upcoming sequel, which also feels distinctly original. Colin Farrell's Oz was a great aspect of The Batman, but he was never the focus. Choosing to tell the story of the first film's red herring is a bold follow-up to a stellar film. However, the connection between the two works is less tight than some might have expected.
Most superhero media fans are used to the works of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, which feverishly strings every person, place, and thing together into a complete mess. Fans tune in to Marvel shows to see which movie characters will wander into the frame with a resulting applause break. Anyone who has seen Matt Reeves' The Batman can probably tell that it will handle the shared universe gimmick very differently. It's a breath of fresh air that connects the stories without feeling too heavy on cameos.
Colin Farrell's The Penguin Prosthetic Suit Was Totally Anatomically Correct
Colin Farrell transformed into the Penguin for Max’s new series, using a prosthetic suit he claims is shockingly anatomically accurate.
The Batman is not in The Penguin
|
Showrunner |
Lauren LeFranc |
|---|---|
|
Stars |
Colin Farrell, Cristin Milioti, Rhenzy Feliz, Deirdre O'Connell |
|
Episodes |
8 |
|
Release Dates |
September 19, 2024–November 10, 2024 |
|
Streaming On |
HBO Max |
The Penguin showrunner Lauren LeFranc and The Batman director Matt Reeves spoke to SFX Magazine a few weeks before the first episode of the show premiered. In the interview, they dispelled rumors that Robert Pattinson would appear as Batman in the series. Outlets reported a ton of conjecture suggesting that Batman would make a cameo appearance in a single episode. In the interview with SFX, LeFranc and Reeves explicitly stated that Batman will not pop up in the new show. He told the outlet:
You're going down a different alley. So the spectre of Batman is there. The spectre of the Riddler is there. The spectre of everything that happens in the last movie is there. It informs it. And it's exactly where we begin.
Only two episodes have hit HBO at this time, but there's been no sign that Batman will appear. It's safe to assume that this isn't a misleading tease or an outright act of deception. The Batman's absence may rub some fans the wrong way. A show about a Batman villain feels incomplete without the Caped Crusader, but there's a perfectly understandable reason why he wouldn't appear in the tale of Oz Cobb.
The Batman is still new in The Penguin
There are two reasonable answers to the question of Batman's absence. The obvious one is the Doylist answer, which is that the show about the Penguin has enough going on to ignore the character who already got his own movie. The Watsonian answer, however, is that the well-established gangsters and criminals have no real reason to worry about the Batman. The 2022 film borrowed heavily from Batman: Year One, establishing Bruce Wayne as a relative newcomer to the crime fighting game. Robert Pattinson's Batman is in the first year of his career. He's not a central piece of Gotham's criminal operations. No one feels the need to talk about him because he's barely a factor in the business they do. Even after Oz's harrowing car chase with him, the Penguin has other things to worry about.
It's a compelling idea in its own right. This means that long-established criminal empires like the Falcone crime family wouldn't have much to worry about from a guy who occasionally beats up street thugs. He isn't much of a threat to the empire at this stage in his career. The film saw Carmine Falcone die at the hands of a different guy in a mask, but Batman was barely a contributing factor. As a result, there's no reason for anyone to bring up the Bat. There are simply bigger things to worry about. The Gotham City of The Penguin is reeling from the massive flood and sudden deaths of several key figures. The biggest concerns on the minds of most underworld figures have nothing to do with Batman. In due time, Batman could build himself into a more notable figure.
Remember the second scene in The Dark Knight? After the Joker pulls off the perfect robbery, the camera follows various criminal activities across Gotham. There's a single, beautifully efficient moment in which one unnamed thug ditches another for fear of running into a Caped Crusader. The irritated would-be felon utters the immortal line, "You got more chance of winning the Powerball than running into him." That came after Batman Begins. The purpose of that scene was to depict the developing culture of fear among Gotham's criminal element. Robert Pattinson's Batman is still between the era of Batman Begins and The Dark Knight. The Penguin is about characters that don't really worry about being punched by a guy in a costume right now. Give them another movie or two, and they won't be able to stop talking about the Bat.
The Penguin's Streaming Premiere Beat A Struggling HBO Prequel
The Penguin's premiere on Max takes over the streaming charts, beating out a record-setting premiere from another massive franchise in the process.