Baldur’s Gate 3 is an outstanding gateway into modern Dungeons & Dragons, as it teaches the language of the systems, showcases iconic spells, and rewards clever thinking with clear, satisfying outcomes. However, BG3 is still a video game built around fast feedback and consequences designed to respect the player's time. Spells are optimized for convenience and clarity, and a lot of their effects are self-contained, with many consequences either softened or reduced to nothingness after the current moment ends. When something goes wrong, the hostility is localized, and players are free to try new tactics or even reload their save just to give another spell a whirl.
Dungeons and Dragons Making Big Change to D&D Beyond
Dungeons and Dragons reveals big plans for D&D Beyond in the near future that could transform how some tables play the TTRPG for the better.
Tabletop D&D operates in a very different way. Spells exist inside a persistent, reactive world run by the DM, meaning that the roles are governed by a human rather than a virtual engine. This means that the world around the players is far more unforgiving and realistic, with NPCs remembering acts of manipulation and information often being incomplete or misleading. A spell that feels safe in BG3 can become a social, narrative, or tactical liability when used in the more open tabletop setting, which can catch many new players off guard when transitioning from the game to the real world.
Friends
Advantages Now, Consequences Later
- Hostility remains after the effect wears off.
- Enchantment magic can carry a social stigma.
In Baldur’s Gate 3, Friends is framed as a harmless social booster that can be used to gain advantage, pass the check, and move on without any real long-term consequences. The spell’s downside barely matters because NPC hostility is localized and often irrelevant once the conversation ends. The cast becomes an isolated action that players can forget about just as quickly as the character themselves. The game trains players to view the spell as a free Persuasion coupon with no long-term cost, leading to frequent uses they can easily get away with in the context of the gaming world.
At a real D&D table, Friends is borderline radioactive. The spell explicitly states that the target becomes hostile once it ends, but this doesn't necessarily mean they are coming for a fight. That merchant will remember being magically manipulated and may close up shop, guards can report the incident and put a whole city on lockdown, and tricksters can use their exploitation as a tool to punish the group further down the line. All of these are likely outcomes spawned from a single spell use, and it means that the real cost of frivolous casting isn't just physical damage, but the potential destruction of a party's reputation and even banishment from an entire settlement.
Detect Thoughts
Reading Minds Comes With Resistance
- Not just a truth button.
- Being caught is worse than not acting at all.
BG3 presents Detect Thoughts as a clean, powerful information tool that should be used frequently to gain leverage in social situations. Casting it during dialogue unlocks hidden options and can extract hidden motivations, allowing the player to either walk away and avoid conflict entirely or to use those extra details to manipulate the NPC. The characters rarely notice, and resist meaningfully in even rarer cases, making the spell feel very safe to use and almost an optimal choice when it comes to conversational Manipulation.
New Dungeons & Dragons Alternative Has a Clear Target
A brand new Dungeons & Dragons alternative focuses on a specific subset of players who are often overlooked in the fantasy TTRPG space.
Tabletop D&D presents a completely different version of Detect Thoughts that shows the spell as invasive and risky above all else. For starters, surface thoughts are often vague and driven by emotion, making them fairly misleading and difficult to use with certainty. Digging deeper requires saving throws, which can either cause a slight informational boost or a complete escalation of the situation, altering the target and leading to a more than unwanted confrontation. Even worse, many NPCs respond badly to having their minds probed, especially those in power or with secrets worth protecting, so players need to think very carefully about an appropriate situation in which to use it and whether the benefits outweigh the major potential costs.
Speak With Animals
Conversations Without Much Substance
- Animals have limited intelligence and details.
- Information can be subjective.
Baldur's Gate 3 treats animals like quirky NPCs with reliable information that can easily be talked to with little to no issues. One simple cast of Speak with Animals and suddenly, wildlife becomes a treasure trove of plot hints, secrets, and emotional honesty that doesn't exist elsewhere in the world. The little critters speak clearly and understand situations perfectly, while rarely having emotional stakes that make other characters decide to mislead or outright reject the player's questions. In a lot of ways, the spell feels like a low-risk information extractor that can be a vital tool for the player's progress through the story.
At the table, animals are still animals. They have limited intelligence, narrower priorities, and unreliable perspectives that can be completely illegible or downright useless at worst. A dog cares about food and territory, not the larger political context of a kingdom, and a bird may exaggerate threats or misunderstand intent based on their own animalistic nature. Worse still, players often assume animals are neutral truth-tellers when, in reality, they can very easily be mistaken or simply not care about the player and their larger goals. An overreliance on animal testimony can derail the party's investigations or cause bad decisions based on incomplete understanding, making the spell a much more situational action that should only come out when the moment is right.
Darkness
Obscuring The Entire Battlefield At Once
- Allies suffer the debuff too.
- Enemies can adapt to spells cast.
BG3 turns Darkness into a powerful, almost surgical combat tool that can effectively turn the tide of battle or completely alter how a combat encounter plays out. Enemy AI struggles inside it, while party members can exploit vision rules cleanly, as not only can they position in a far more strategic manner, but they will also be prepared well before the effect comes down. In larger scenarios, the spell feels like a reliable way to dominate encounters with minimal downside, and there are countless instances of players using it to great effect at every stage of the game.
When it comes to tabletop D&D, however, Darkness is far more chaotic and unclear. It affects allies as much as enemies, leading to disruptive spell targeting, and it can even confuse the team's positioning due to the lack of clarity on the battlefield. Also, many creatures can leave the area or actively exploit it better than players expect, making that reckless cast a dire mistake that will soon come back to bite the party. Arguably, the biggest reason the spell is so much less consistent is the DM's enforcement of the rules. They may be strict about the real impact of this lack of vision. What starts as control quickly becomes disorder, especially in tight spaces, and only time will tell if the spell proves beneficial or catastrophic for the player and their blinded friends.
Disguise Self
Looking The Part Doesn't Mean Acting It
- Role-playing remains central.
- Illusions don't replace preparation.
BG3 gives players a power tool in Disguise Self, which can be used as a near-perfect infiltration technique that almost never fails. NPCs rarely question appearances, and disguises often hold up indefinitely unless explicitly challenged, meaning that players can either use them to blend in with the crowd or even the complete opposite, to be treated in a specific, racially driven manner to get on the inside. This leads to plenty of funny and interesting situations where a single disguise can be all it takes to gain a huge amount of information and leverage from a clueless group or individual.
Dungeons & Dragons: The Best Archfey Patrons
The Archfey is one of the most fun warlock subclasses in D&D, and these patrons are the best for this category.
D&D takes a much more restrictive path when dealing with Disguise Self. While it does change appearances, it keeps the player's voice, mannerisms, and knowledge intact. Right from the start, characters will begin asking questions and expect a level of familiarity that simply doesn't exist, and the true effectiveness of the disguise relies solely on the player's ability to play the part and stay in character until they are safe. On top of this, physical interactions can break the illusion instantly, and therefore, one mistake can expose the entire ruse and escalate the whole situation dramatically before anyone has a chance to undo things.
8 Common Monsters in Dungeons & Dragons That Become Total Nightmares At Higher Levels
Beware these 8 seemingly harmless monsters that become total nightmares at higher levels in D&D!